mastodon.ar.al is one of the many independent Mastodon servers you can use to participate in the fediverse.
This is my personal fediverse server.

Administered by:

Server stats:

1
active users

Aral Balkan

Web 1.0: We gather data when you visit our web site
Web 2.0: We gather data when you visit every web site
Web 3.0: We buy your government and get the data straight from your treasury

#musk#trump#USA

@aral Web 3.0 : we hack your data and lock your accounts and you have no power to stop us.

@aral

Web 4.0: "Stay in that fucking pod and allow that dripfeed up your ass, Neo."

@smallcircles @aral aral just blocked me because i said web 3.0 is the semantic web of Tim Berners-Lee and should not be confused with web3 of the cryptobros.

he really needs to calm down...

@nextgraph yes, my own strategy in these dark times is to do a minimal of awareness / wake up calling now and then, here and there boost of a doomscroll-related toot if relevant, and then seek out positivity and optimism, uplifting toots to boost, or create myself. That will lead to a more effective and productive commons, and stronger fist to dark forces.

@nextgraph @smallcircles @aral That really bums me out EVERY time... But I am getting tired of explaining the difference in these kinds of heated discussions / rants.

You don't see the bigger problem. You've allowed for governments to grow powerful and collect almost unlimited data and you didn't care UNTIL someone you don't like got into power.
Never give a government anything you wouldn't hand to the worst possible person running it, whoever that is in your view.

@gvs “The NSA didn't wake up and say, ‘Let's just spy on everybody.’ They looked up and said, ‘Wow, corporations are spying on everybody. Let's get ourselves a copy.’”

—Bruce Schneier

@gvs (And yes, I agree with you that neoliberalism built the groundwork for fascism. The lie we were told was that capitalism was a prerequisite for democracy when capitalism is cancer for democracy.)

So many things here. Neoliberalism is the opposite of capitalism, it requires state interventions in marktets. Capitalism is the only economic model that can exist in a free society and democracy is the cancer that will kill us all.
But to the point, it is the rise of technology and the growth of governemt that created the problem. If we have technology, it needs to be kept away from the most dangerous part of society.
As much as I like Schneier, I think that is only part true. And as much as I dislike corporations spying (I don't have facebook, WhatsApp and I have a degoogled phone), the government spying is much, much worse as it aggregates multiple sources, it can't be opted out (by not using the service) and their reasons are even worse.

@gvs the government issues your social security number and passport. They are who you file your taxes with too. The Treasury Dept is where you pay your taxes to or get your federal refund from. The IRS has all of your W-2s and financial info.

@aral

If you axed income taxes and replaced it with VAT only, the government would have no need to know your income.

@gvs too late. Elon has all the information already.

@aral

Which is why I said you should never give governments anything you wouldn't like to see in the hands of the worst possible party in your view. Which that is differs for everyone. I don't trust Musk/Trump any more or less then Biden or Obama or Bush

@gvs apparently, you missed the part about your social security and passports being issued by the government? Not paying taxes is illegal. If you are trying to create future policies, you should edit your first comment to reflect that.

To be clear, this is not legal. It is a coup and cyberattack on the US government

@aral

You misread my first reply in that case. I suggested that the population made a giant mistake handing large amounts of data and power to government only to whine when that government got led by someone they dislike. It's unfixable right now, but we can close the tap now before mopping up the water that is already on the floor.

@gvs who do you propose does the job of the government then? Who assigns things like passports and social security numbers? The lesson here is not that the government can’t be trusted, it’s that anything can be hacked. Btw, Elon is not even actually part of the federal government.

@aral

You don't need social security numbers. And yes, passports have to be trusted by other governments so you need one to issue them.

But governments share your data with private parties all the time, you didn't seem to mind that before that party was Musk and that is the mistake. Their shouldn't be anything on a passport that should not leak.

@gvs “You don't need social security numbers.” That is your opinion, it is not a fact. All countries have a way to identify citizens.

“But governments share your data with private parties all the time, you didn't seem to mind that before that party was Musk and that is the mistake.” Nope, they do not do it like this and certainly not all of it. Also, this is a bad faith argument, as this is not a legal means of sharing information that is supposed to be kept private and secure.

@aral

@tweetsjen
A national number, yes. Probably in the US they are not separate things. Yet I fail to how those should be a secret.

The second is just insane. You are telling me that before Musk, which has a task assigned by your government, no private company was involved in processing, storing or anything else with private data of citizens?

But again, not arguing for this, stating that government shouldn't have had most data in the first place.
@aral

@gvs social security and passport numbers serve different functions. If you do not know why they need to be kept secret, please post yours here. This is clearly another bad faith argument.

Some gov systems & databases may be built by contractors, but it’s gov property. You are arguing for less security than the US gov. The US gov has been secure for far longer than any other company in existence.

I don’t have time to argue bad arguments. Run for office if you think you can do better

@aral

I am not a US citizen and Belgian national numbers are hardly a secret (and based on your birthdate with a 3 digit serial behind it) The first kid in 2025 is 250101001. Again, the problem why these should be kept secret comes from government itself.

Secondly, how is any other government contractor different from this? Again, arguing not for Musk and his team but against putting lots of data in the hands of a dangerous entity (government) is a bad idea.

I refuse to vote, so I'm not running for government either.

@gvs ok, at least you have a reason for not understanding. Social security is required to work in the US. A small fee is paid per paycheck to the social security fund that the person can draw in retirement. The passport number is to identify US citizens when they are abroad. Both are linked to your identify. Identify fraud can occur if other people have these numbers. In my opinion, it is better to have separate numbers than one, prevents all areas from being hacked with a single number

@aral

@gvs Musk is not a government contractor as there is no federal contract he is signed on to for this work. He is not elected, appointed, or a federal employee either. He is a private citizen, without any requisite security clearances or required Ethics trainings.

@aral

I don't know if I should laugh or cry about ethics training and bureaucrats. There is nothing I trust less then politicians and that isn't a hyperbole.

@gvs well, I do not think it is a coincidence that this is the first time background checks, security clearances, and ethics were fully disregarded. They told us what they were going to do before they started.

@aral

Our national id serves the same function as both of those, yet they aren't very confidential. They're printed on all forms handled anywhere, employers have them and again, partly predictable. There's not much you can do when you have it either.

We also have passport numbers, but they aren't a form of identification, their unique to the document and not a secret.

Again, governments should not have massive amounts of data on people and then this wouldn't be the big deal it is now.

@gvs identity fraud is rampant in the US and it is a major problem. Credit cards and other lines of credit can be opened in your name and even if you get them resolved, your credit score can be impacted for a long time.

How does Belgium handle identity and financial fraud if these identifiers are not secret?

@aral

@tweetsjen @aral you can't get a credit card here with a social security number. You need to show a passport or ID card. Again, that number is everywhere. Even in the papers of my kids' schools.

@gvs so, do criminals not take advantage of that? How do you not have a major problem? Why are criminals even bothering with getting US identifiers if it is so much easier to do in other countries?

@aral

Because it's not something that you can easily abuse. My National ID is everywhere and therefor easy to find should it have value but without my ID card/passport and signature it's worthless. There's not much you can do when you have it. you certainly can't get credit with it.

@gvs people can make counterfeit ID cards. A lot of this is online and they don’t ask for the actual card for everything. Someone can hack into your current financial information. It’s not just credit cards, identity fraud can be someone else getting your tax refund or applying for unemployment in your name. They could even apply for an apartment or buy a car in your name. It’s a serious, wide-scale problem in the US. That you don’t understand this does not make it any less of one.

@aral